I’ve been writing the “Aesop’s Corner” column in our Family Wealth Decisions Group newsletter for more than 10 years. The purpose of the column is to bring home some modern lessons from some well-known old tales.
There’s a non-Aesop story I remembered hearing from my father when I was very young. It was intended at that time only to generate a smile or a laugh. I had forgotten all about it until I heard it again more recently from local clergy who intended it for its ability to serve as a modern lesson.
The story as I remember it: A man is on his hands and knees under a streetlight, clearly looking for something. A policeman comes by and asks what he is doing. The man responds that he is looking for keys he dropped. After some period of time, the policeman asks if he is sure he lost the keys in this location. The man replies he dropped it two blocks away. The policeman then asked the man why he is looking here. The man responded that the light was better here.
Apparently, this story actually depicts a “thing” referred to as the streetlight effect. Wikipedia describes the streetlight effect as a type of observational bias when people tend to look for things where it is most convenient to do so1. The streetlight provides no help for the search in question. A successful search in this case would require the man to be willing to look in areas beyond the light and beyond his comfort zone.
One of my favorite quotations is attributed to Mark Twain: “It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so2.” This describes an iteration of the streetlight effect where reliance on potentially erroneous assumptions (what you think you know for sure that just isn’t so) may be easier than working to verify them. The search for the truth or the right answer may be more difficult if the search process is contaminated by constraints of assumptions, ease and convenience.
What else do we do because it is easier or more convenient than it is helpful? From a financial planning perspective, often advice is given to make changes in lifestyle costs, investments and estate plan documents. Sometimes the changes recommended appear overwhelming or are unfamiliar and may cause some anxiety as a result. It may be easier and more convenient to maintain the status quo due to the comfort offered by familiarity, but it may not be in your best interest to do so.
Financial objectives, tax law, family situations, risk tolerance and financial condition may change over time. Often these changed circumstances require financial planning changes to address them. How can you get more comfortable with making changes?
One thing that can help is a better understanding of the financial principles relevant to your financial situation that may suggest that moving out of your comfort zone is the right move. Some basic education can help overcome the overconfidence awarded to assumptions which appear easier, more familiar and more convenient. These assumptions are often based on mental shortcuts designed to speed up and simplify decisions, instead of being based on relevant research and data3.
Another way to potentially minimize the impact of the streetlight effect is to be aware that you have biases. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines a bias as “implying an unreasoned and unfair distortion of judgment in favor of or against a person or thing4.” One cognitive bias such as the streetlight effect can be exacerbated by another. For example, a confirmation bias that supports seeking out data that confirms our assumptions may encourage continuing to look for answers under the streetlight5.
In summary, we are all susceptible to remaining in our comfort zone. After all, it’s the comfort zone. But if we truly want good answers to life’s challenges, we need to be prepared to move away from the streetlight. The Family Wealth Decisions Group lighthouse logo expresses our desire and ability to help our clients illuminate the shadows to make the search for solutions less daunting.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect
3. https://www.investopedia.com/overconfidence-bias-7485796#
4. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bias
5. https://www.august.com.au/blog/four-ways-to-avoid-streetlight-effect-marketing-data-analysis/